Asking an applicant for proof of income can feel like a wild choose-your-own-adventure book.
The days of a simple one-size-fits-all paycheck verification are long gone. Today's applicant pool includes more and more freelancers, commission-based professionals, and individuals utilizing housing assistance programs.
To help you navigate this complex landscape while keeping your leasing team compliant with Fair Housing guidelines, we have broken down the major employment categories to explain the proof of income you should ask for in each scenario.
1. Traditional Employment / Standard W-2 Employees
This is the most straightforward category; individuals who work a standard corporate or hourly job with regular payroll processing.
What to ask for: The 3 most recent consecutive paystubs. If they are paid weekly, ask for 6 weeks of paystubs.
Don’t forget to check: Verify that the applicant's name, the date, the hourly rate and number of hours are clearly visible.
What Bemrose calculates:
Gross monthly income = regular hourly rate x average weekly hours x 52 weeks in a year / 12 months.
Income from tips is generally not considered, as it is nonguaranteed income / fluctuates constantly.
Applicants Employed Through Family
When an applicant works for a family-owned business or a close relative, standard paystubs can easily be fabricated or manipulated, making standard verification unreliable.
What to ask for: Official tax returns from the most recent tax year. This could be a 1040 form (first page only) or the state tax form.
Why it matters: Tax documents filed directly with the government provide an audited, official record of true earnings, eliminating the risk of inflated or artificial "family-rate" paystubs.
2. Independent & Performance-Based Income
Self-Employed & Freelance Workers
Entrepreneurs, independent contractors, and gig workers don't have paystubs. Their income often fluctuates month-to-month, so we need to look at longer-term averages.
What to ask for: The 3 most recent months of personal bank statements OR their most recent tax return.
Note we do not accept 1099 forms from self-employed professionals because they are generated by individuals themselves and can easily be fabricated/manipulated.
Don’t forget to check: Verify that the applicant’s name, the date, and the name of the bank are clearly visible. Make sure there are three monthly periods included.
What Bemrose looks for: Does the applicant have an average bank balance 12x, 24x, or 36x the rent? (Cosigners may be required to have more, depending on your criteria). If not, do they have average monthly deposits equal to or greater than 3x the rent? When reviewing taxes, we look at the gross income to calculate average income and verify overall stability.
Commission-Based Professionals
Salespeople, real estate agents, and corporate recruiters often make a low base salary but high overall compensation due to commissions. Looking at a single paystub won't tell you the whole story.
What to ask for: Most recent tax form—accept either a W-2, a 1040, or a state tax form.
Why it matters: Relying on recent paystubs might show an unusually low or artificially high month. A full tax document gives you a reliable average of their real annual earnings.
3. Non-Employment & Multi-Stream Income
Applicants with Non-Employment Income
Many highly qualified applicants do not have traditional jobs but possess reliable, guaranteed monthly income from government, military, or retirement programs.
What to ask for:
A formal housing voucher (e.g., Section 8 or local nonprofit documents). Please note that we can’t accept housing voucher worksheets, the preliminary paperwork given to applicants. We must have a signed letter defining the amount to be provided to applicant.
An official Social Security benefits letter
An official ODHS benefits letter
A VA (Veterans Affairs) benefits letter
A pension benefits letter (varies greatly)
A notarized copy of court document for child support showing the monthly dollar amount
Applicants with Multiple Streams of Income
Some applicants make a living from multiple part-time gigs, investments, child support, or side hustles, making individual paystubs or forms impractical to trace.
What to ask for: The 3 most recent months of personal bank statements OR their tax return.
Don’t forget to check: Verify that the applicant’s name, the date, and the name of the bank are clearly visible. Make sure there are three monthly periods included.
What Bemrose looks for: Does the applicant have an average bank balance 12x, 24x, or 36x the rent? (Cosigners may be required to have more, depending on your criteria). If not, do they have average monthly deposits equal to or greater than 3x the rent? When reviewing taxes, we look at the gross income to calculate average income and verify overall stability.
A good rule of thumb: Bank statements and taxes provide a snapshot of an applicant’s recent income. While W-2 employees MUST provide income verification from their job, the best way to verify income for applicants that have complicated income is through bank statements or taxes.
The golden rule: Be consistent. Treat every applicant within a specific employment category exactly the same. By standardizing these specific document requests based on employment type, you ensure compliance, protect your property, and build a smooth, professional leasing process for everyone.
Next up: Students, new hires, and cosigners!
Share this list at your next team huddle!
DISCLAIMER: READ CAREFULLY: The information provided in this article is not considered legal advice and is given only for information purposes. ALWAYS SEEK THE ADVICE OF YOUR LEGAL COUNSEL.